By Jason Phelps, REALTOR®, Bedrock Homes
Thanksgiving is my favorite holiday. No gifts, no pressure, just people around a table. And the more I learned about where it came from, the more I appreciated it. The holiday we celebrate wasn’t built in a day. It was built in layers, over 400 years, by a lot of different people. That’s a lot like a home: what lasts is what’s built on a solid foundation.
Here’s the story we weren’t taught in school, and the surprising history behind the sides on your table this year.
What really happened in 1621
The event we call “the first Thanksgiving” was a harvest celebration at Plymouth in the fall of 1621. It wasn’t called Thanksgiving at the time, and the only written description is a single paragraph in a letter by colonist Edward Winslow.
What we know: after the English fired guns to celebrate their harvest, the Wampanoag leader Massasoit (also known as Ousamequin) arrived with about 90 men. Historians still debate whether they were invited or came to see what the gunfire was about. The Wampanoag hunted and brought five deer, and the feast lasted three days. Turkey is never mentioned.
The two groups had signed an agreement of mutual protection that spring, and both had long traditions of harvest celebrations. For the Wampanoag, it was a moment of diplomacy at a hard time, not the start of a holiday. It’s an honest, more complicated story than the one in our school plays, and I think it makes the day more meaningful, not less.
How it became a national holiday
For more than two centuries, “thanksgiving” days were set state by state, on different dates. The holiday we know exists largely because of one persistent woman: Sarah Josepha Hale, a magazine editor who campaigned for 36 years for a national day of Thanksgiving, writing to president after president.
In September 1863, in the middle of the Civil War, she wrote to Abraham Lincoln. A few days later, on October 3, 1863, Lincoln proclaimed a national Thanksgiving on the last Thursday of November.
One more twist: in 1939, Franklin Roosevelt moved Thanksgiving up a week to lengthen the holiday shopping season, and critics nicknamed it “Franksgiving.” It was so unpopular that in 1941 Congress set Thanksgiving on the fourth Thursday of November, where it’s been ever since.
Hale also published turkey and stuffing recipes for years in her magazine, which helped shape the menu we still serve.
Why the sides are the sides
Most of what’s on today’s Thanksgiving table wasn’t at the 1621 feast. Each side has its own story, and each one is linked to a top-rated recipe if you’re cooking this year.
Stuffing (or dressing). Stuffing goes back to ancient Rome: a 1st-century cookbook credited to Apicius has recipes for stuffed meats. The word “dressing” took hold in the 1800s, when “stuffing” sounded too crude for Victorian manners. Here in the South, cornbread dressing reflects African American cooking traditions. Try: Grandma’s Corn Bread Dressing, Allrecipes’ most-saved Thanksgiving dressing.
Green bean casserole. This one is surprisingly young. Dorcas Reilly, a home economist in Campbell Soup’s test kitchen, created it in 1955 using cream of mushroom soup and fried onions. Try: The Best Green Bean Casserole, a from-scratch version rated 4.5 stars from 894 votes.
Sweet potato casserole. Neither sweet potatoes nor white potatoes were at the 1621 feast. Candied sweet potatoes have deep roots in Southern and African American cooking. The marshmallow topping started as marketing: a marshmallow company hired cooking-school founder Janet McKenzie Hill to put marshmallows in a recipe booklet, and her baked sweet potatoes with marshmallows caught on. Try: Yummy Sweet Potato Casserole, 4.8 stars from nearly 2,900 reviews.
Mashed potatoes. White potatoes hadn’t reached New England in 1621, and the first recorded mashed potato recipe appeared in an English cookbook in 1747. Hale’s Thanksgiving menus helped make them a staple. Try: Easy Garlic Mashed Potatoes, 4.97 stars from 65 votes.
Cranberry sauce. Cranberries are native here, and the Wampanoag still hold a fall Cranberry Day harvest festival. Canned cranberry sauce arrived in 1912 from the company now called Ocean Spray. Try: Sally’s 5-Ingredient Cranberry Sauce, 4.8 stars from 168 reviews.
Corn pudding. Corn may be the side with the strongest tie to 1621: it was a Wampanoag staple and a big part of the colonists’ first harvest. Try: Grandma’s Corn Pudding, 4.6 stars from more than 900 ratings.
Built on a foundation
I named my team Bedrock Homes because everything good is built on a solid foundation: a home, a family, a tradition. Thanksgiving is proof. A harvest meal in 1621, a determined editor in the 1800s, a president in wartime, a 1955 test kitchen, your grandmother’s dressing recipe. Each generation added a layer.
Whatever’s on your table this year, I hope it’s surrounded by people you love. And if next Thanksgiving you’d like to host in a new home, I’d be glad to help you find it.
Happy Thanksgiving from my family to yours.
Common questions
Was turkey served at the first Thanksgiving? It isn’t mentioned. Winslow’s account mentions “fowl,” which could have been ducks or geese, and the Wampanoag brought five deer.
Why is Thanksgiving on a Thursday? Lincoln’s 1863 proclamation chose the last Thursday of November. Since 1941, federal law has set it on the fourth Thursday.
Who is the “mother of Thanksgiving”? Sarah Josepha Hale, the editor whose decades of letters helped convince Lincoln to make it a national holiday.
Sources: Smithsonian Magazine; National Museum of the American Indian; History.com; Library of Congress; Live Science; Mental Floss. Recipe ratings as shown on each site in November 2026.
Jason Phelps, REALTOR® · Bedrock Homes, a team of Coldwell Banker Realty · Equal Housing Opportunity.